Commander may be the most widespread way to play MTG, however, in my investment in packs, nothing that matches a draft. Whether you venture to your local game store on a weekend evening or convene with friends, few things rival the sensation of cracking a few packs and building a limited deck for a brisk MTG competition.
Drafting evens out the competitive landscape (there's no way to simply buy victory over your rivals to secure victory), and additionally, you go home with a pile of new cards to add to your EDH decks. Nevertheless, there’s a growing concern in draft (and in Magic's other limited play mode, sealed) that’s only worsening as Wizards of the Coast and its parent company continue to ramp up Universes Beyond. The problem boils down to two key terms: legendary rule.
Understanding the Legendary Conundrum
MTG’s 30-year history is full of imaginative creatures, from archetypal staples like goblins and elves and iconic original races like phyrexians and eldrazi. A much smaller portion of those creatures is designated as legendary, which indicates that rather than representing an entire swath of creatures, the individual card depicts a unique persona in the Magic multiverse.
The designation of being legendary also has a a number of rules consequences in the game. Firstly, legendary permanents are typically more powerful and rare than their non-legendary counterparts, though that’s shifted in modern design. There’s also the notorious legend rule, which states: If two or more legendary permanents with the same name are controlled by the same player, that player chooses one of them, and the rest are put into their owners' graveyards.
This implies you can’t control two of the same legendary permanent at the same time, or create a copy (except if you have some sort of exception). This doesn’t matter much in Commander/EDH, where decks are only allowed a single copy of each card, but in draft, where there are unlimited copies allowed, it’s considerably more problematic.
The Universes Beyond Effect Exacerbates the Problem
Historically, this wasn’t a problem. Most sets use legendary creatures sparingly, especially when it comes to lower rarity cards. However, with crossover properties, that’s no longer the situation. The recent Spider-Man set was brimming with them, with a sizable majority of the creatures being legendary-designated, encompassing a substantial share of the common creatures. Magic’s newest crossover expansion, TMNT, is no different, and it is anticipated that other future Universes Beyond sets like Marvel Heroes and Star Trek will emulate this approach.
This causes an evident problem in draft and sealed formats where the tried-and-true tactic is frequently to create a cohesive deck by selecting as multiple of the identical cards as possible. In a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles draft, you might be tempted to draft several copies of a synergistic card since it synergizes well with itself, but you’ll ultimately only play one at a time due to the legend rule.
The Simple Remedy
In a notable blog post, the game’s lead designer, responded to this concern head on. The primary advantage is a greater number of players have the chance to open up a booster pack with a card of their favorite character,” the post explained.
To some extent, this is understandable. Whether you like it or not, the aim of crossovers is to bring beloved stories into Magic, and playing with the heroes from those universes is a central aspect of that experience. However, a great many of these franchises also don’t have a large roster of unnamed creatures to pick from, which is the reason you end up with uninspired cards in crossover expansions. There often aren't enough non-unique creative choices to properly fill a full set of Magic cards.
In the aforementioned blog post, it was also mentioned that there have been efforts to remove the restriction (unsuccessfully) for years.”
Well, it could be time to pull the trigger and delete the legend rule — not for all of Magic, but for draft and limited, only. After all, limited decks already deviate from other formats by letting you play as many duplicates of a card as you draft; other formats restrict you to a playset per card. Removing the legend rule in this specific case addresses the issue with very few obvious negative consequences (the chances of someone acquiring two copies of an mythic rare legendary creature are low).
This elegant fix could save Magic: The Gathering drafts. Admittedly, one could also just cancel the crossover program entirely. That would address the issue, as well. Until such a drastic measure is taken, temporarily ignoring the legend rule for a few specific formats would work just fine.